Comprehensive guide to end-to-end print security
It doesn’t take much to convince organizations nowadays on the importance of security and protecting sensitive information that is stored digitally, in mid-transit, or being printed from the printer. Just take a moment and think about all the security measures you’ve put in place in the last 10 years, and then compare that to how much you know about the security of your print jobs.
This article specifically focuses on securing print jobs in transit, and how they can be protected from snooping eyes. In other words, end-to-end encryption of print jobs on the network. For additional information about securing your print environment in general, refer to our security whitepaper.
Security is not a set-and-forget activity. To ensure protection for today and for the future, we’ll guide you through how to:
- Validate, and
- Maintain encryption of print jobs on your network.
This article promised to be a “comprehensive guide” so let’s get into the detail and get your print jobs secure. Here is a quick summary of areas that we’ll be covering, so you can jump to a specific one if you wish to:
Out of the box, Windows printing system uses Server Message Block (SMB) to print spool files to the server, which is the same protocol used for file sharing. Traffic is encrypted since SMB2, which was improved upon in SMB3.
Unfortunately, due to the Print Nightmare mitigations included in every Windows release since mid-2021, the efficacy of SMB printer sharing has been significantly undermined. You can read more about this in our “What is Print Nightmare” article.
Recommended practice: Consider switching off SMB1 on your server if you need to continue using Server Message Block. Note that this isn’t going to work for clients running anything before Windows Vista on your network (remember Windows Vista?).
Don’t worry, your users will love you for the upgrade - who doesn’t like a new laptop anyway? (That is rhetorical, you don’t have to comment their name if you know someone.😜)
You can switch off SMB1 with this command:
Set-SmbServerConfiguration –EnableSMB1Protocol $false
Considerations with Mobility Print on Windows
As you work around the Print Nightmare Mitigations, you may find yourself ready to install PaperCut Mobility Print - great choice!
By default, Windows will not encrypt its connection to our Mobility Print service. To get around this and make sure your jobs are traveling securely across the network you can choose one of two options.
If you want your users to be able to print to your environment, no matter where they are:
You may be interested in our Mobility Print cloud solution! You can share the printer out through the Mobility Print cloud connection, and all jobs that are sent will travel through a secure tunnel established via WebRTC. You can read more about Mobility Print’s cloud print here in our manual.
If you only want your users to print when they are connected to your network:
You can deploy a Mobility Print queue with our Print Deploy solution! This allows you to use either the standard generic driver or a manufacturer-specific driver if you need. All Mobility Print jobs submitted to queues deployed with Print Deploy will be encrypted. You can find out how to set this up in our Print Deploy manual.
Both of these options will use a local reverse proxy to install a normal, unencrypted, IPP queue on the client machine. When the job hits the queue, our application will accept the job, and deliver it over an HTTPS connection to the Mobility Print server. This is important to consider, as it will not allow for you to completely disable unencrypted printing on a policy level - rather you can allow for IPP printing to the localhost address, and nowhere else.
MacOS computers print to Windows print servers on one of the following protocols:
- IPPS (recommended)
LPR/LPD is not encrypted, and if you’ve made it this far through this article, it would appear that security is important to you so let’s just skip this one and not use it.
In all honesty, managing SMB printers on a Mac, whether it is BYOD or a managed device is often not worth it. I recommend you go straight for IPPS. But, if you do go for SMB, at least your print jobs will be encrypted over the network.
IPPS is IPP over an HTTPS connection. Inherently it uses the same level of encryption you would get on an HTTPS web page. MacOS computers do accept self-signed certificates, read more about considerations under iOS clients.
You have two options to deploy IPPS:
Deploy Mobility Print. Mobility Print works extremely well in a mixed environment where some devices are managed, and others are BYOD or even mobile devices. Both are able to connect to the Mobility Print server and authenticate securely.
Mobility Print can be deployed on a Windows server, so an additional MacOS server is not required. Mobility Print will use HTTPS for client connections.
Deploy a MacOS server. With a MacOS server, you can deploy additional tools such as Kerberos if you want your users to avoid entering their credentials when printing. The additional overhead and cost required to configure and manage the additional server and clients often prompts organizations to use Mobility Print instead.
Note however, that both iOS and MacOS devices accept self-signed certificates. On the open internet, where there are many hops between you and the server, a self-signed certificate is not secure because any of these hops can introduce a man-in-the-middle attack. On a local network however, the risk is considerably less, especially in a switched network environment.
Best practice: If you want to minimize the risk of man-in-the-middle attacks , make sure you use secure wifi protocols, and consider using security tools that actively monitor for address spoofing attempts.
PaperCut’s Android Mobility Print app uses encrypted printing for Android devices out of the box. Print jobs are sent to the Mobility Print server over HTTPS. Similar to iOS and MacOS, self-signed certificates are accepted.
When using Mobility Print, 256-bit level AES encryption is applied to all print jobs.
Firstly, you need to check whether your printer supports IPPS. Check your printer specification.
If your printers support IPPS, you are in luck, as you can set up an encrypted connection between your print server and the printer. If your printers only support LPD, then there are still a few things you can do to avoid someone snooping and capturing the print jobs, which will be explained below.
IPPS between the server and printers PaperCut MF and NG can securely forward print jobs to printers over IPPS. Follow this guide on how to configure IPPS printers and PaperCut MF and NG.
How to secure printers that do not support IPPS As print jobs won’t be encrypted, your only defence is to separate network traffic between your server and printers from the rest of the network.
Firstly, configure your printers on a different VLAN. Secondly, to ensure someone can’t access the private VLAN by pulling out a network cable from a printer, follow the user manual of your switch to configure port security to only accept your printer’s MAC address.
Checking whether encryption to a website is configured, is pretty easy. Simply open a browser and see whether it complains about the security.
Checking the encryption of print jobs is slightly more involved, and a little bit more fun. You’ll need Wireshark to analyse network protocols and for instructions on how to use Wireshark to validate that your jobs are secure, follow this guide.
As mentioned earlier, an important part of security is maintenance. All too often, vulnerabilities occur through lack of maintenance. This is often a forgotten step so here are our top tips on making your print environment more secure:
- Document your security policies and design. If you leave one day, someone should be able to pick up from where you left off.
- Keep your printers on a different VLAN or dedicated IP range, and disable all protocols except IPPS.
- Switch on auto updates to get the latest security updates for software and operating systems.
- Sign up for security notifications from Microsoft.
- Create Google Alerts for:
- MacOS security alert
- iOS security alert
- ChromeOS security alert
- Android security alert
- IPPS security alert
- Share your practices and document within your organization. Don’t be surprised when your next pay review includes a nice raise.
Well done! You have not only secured your organisation for the present, but you’ve put in place practices that will keep your organisation secure far into the future. Through all of this, you might have picked up a salary raise. You can now feel good going on a weekend away, knowing that you’ve got your organisation’s back. Proceed to work towards an Apply, Validate and Maintain approach for the other areas of your IT infrastructure!
Keywords: security , encryption , end-to-end encryption
Last updated November 16, 2022